
Welcome to
First Churches of Northampton
We welcome all in joyful Christian community.
We listen for God's still-speaking voice.
We work together to make God's love and justice real.

Proud members of the UCC Open and Affirming Coalition and the Association of Welcoming and Affirming Baptists

"Nothing Ventured, Nothing Gained: The Terrible Parable of the Talents"
the same could also be said for Jesus’ parables. That is to say that no one parable is going to give us all the answers. Some will give us more than others, but no one story can possibly say it all.
Take the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. Those young ladies teach us a great deal about the importance of being well prepared, but they teach us absolutely nothing about how to share. The shepherd who leaves the 99 for one lost sheep teaches us a whole lot about God’s love, but very little about responsible herding practices.
And all those parables we read about kings, masters, and slaves say a heck of a lot about actions and consequences, but not a one challenges the social order enough to suggest that, say, slavery be abolished. That took some reading between the lines. That took a little deductive reasoning. Abolishing slavery required people to take a step back and look at the Biblical picture as a whole. So you see, no one sermon or story can say it all. Even Jesus’ parables are a little bit heretical.
And I think this is good news, in fact it may be the best news you’ll hear this morning because today we’re taking a closer look at “The Parable of the Talents,” and this story has a little something to offend everyone. Am I right?
Is there anyone here who felt entirely comfortable with this parable as it was being read or happy with how it played out?
Me either. I mean this story, at least at first, strikes me as misguided with its focus on building up treasures on earth, inequitable in its redistribution of wealth, and mercilessly unfair in its treatment of the third slave.
For starters: did anyone notice that the game was stacked against the little guy from the very beginning? Not only are the slaves given different sums, they are all given sums in accordance with their level of ability.
The master gives the third slave less to start out with because the master already knows that the third slave is not as competent as the first two. And yet, the master still holds him up to the same level of expectation as the others when he returns. That isn’t just unfair or inequitable, it’s cruel.
Not only that, the master chastises the third slave for not at least putting his money in the bank to gain interest, which was actually a big “no, no!” back in Jesus’ day.
Now I’ll admit that this isn’t something we talk about a whole lot in our churches now because frankly I don’t know how we would function if we took this seriously, but you need to know that lending money at interest –that same practice that makes it possible for people to use credit cards, obtain mortgages, and helps this church live off its endowment - is a practice that is condemned as sinful in both the Old and New Testament. Yeah. Sorry.
The fact that the third slave refused to lend out the master’s money should be a point in his favor. Instead, he ran off and hid it in the ground like good respectable people did back in those days. Which means that he didn’t actually do anything wrong, and yet here he is getting punished for making the courageous and countercultural decision to obey the law of God rather than just make money.
Which is to say that something is amiss here. In fact, I could stand here all morning and come up with things that feel off about this parable, but I’ll content myself with pointing out just one more questionable detail, and that is the supposed moral of this sorry little tale.
“For to all those who have, more will be given, and they will have an abundance;” says the Master, “but from those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away. As for this worthless slave, throw him into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.'”
Honestly, that’s the part that upsets me the most. Anybody else? Yeah! I mean, what is going on here? This is Jesus talking, but he doesn’t sound like the Jesus I know and love at all.
I mean, whatever happened to the meek inheriting the earth? And what about the poor? Didn’t Jesus say that theirs is the kingdom of heaven? Isn’t the love of money the root of all evil? And what about grace, forgiveness, mercy? Or the first being last and the last being first? Something is amiss here. In fact a whole lot is missing here.
This can’t be the whole story, and indeed it isn’t. The truth is that you are going to need to consult the rest of your Bible to understand how to live as a Christian. Likewise, you’re going to have to read this parable in the context of that same Bible if you really want to understand what it means. And we’re going to get to that, but first I want you to fully understand just how upsetting this story has been for people throughout the ages.
According to my late preaching professor, the Rev. Peter Gomes, “this tale so affected Karl Marx that he (went ahead,) reversed its implications and came up with his classical theory of socialism: ‘From each according to his ability; to each according to his needs’” (Sermons: Biblical Wisdom for Daily Living p 200).
Likewise, this parable was so upsetting to people in the early church that they just went ahead and rewrote it. In later apocryphal versions of the story the first slave invests and increases the money, the second hides and preserves it, and the third goes out and gambles it away. The first two are rewarded by the master when he returns, and the third is justly punished for misusing his master’s money (“Pulpit Resource” Vol. 33, No. 4 p 30 by William H. Willimon).
People liked that version. Not only did it make sense, it also taught a little something about fiscal responsibility. Only problem is that it’s not the story Jesus told. If you take it out of context and mess with it, you can make the Parable of the Talents mean just about anything you want.
But here’s the thing. When you look at it in the context of Jesus’ life and ministry you come to realize something quite striking and not a little disturbing. You come to realize that this isn’t actually a parable about money at all. Nope.
The Parable of the Talents is actually about the end of time, the end of Jesus’ time on earth and hence the time between His ascension and His return. It is a parable about the Kingdom of God in the mean time.
We are nearing the end of Matthew’s gospel. Jesus’ earthly ministry is about to come to a close and he has 3 more stories to tell before he is arrested and hauled away to be tried and crucified. This is his second to last parable, sandwiched between the one about the wise and foolish virgins and his story about the separation of the sheep from the goats.
Jesus doesn’t know when he’ll be back, so he tells the people that living in the meantime will be like ten virgins waiting for a bridegroom, 5 of whom were ready to greet him when he returned because they kept their lamps…(anyone?) trimmed and burning (thank you choir!).
What Jesus does know is that he is about to be taken away for a long time, so he tells them that the kingdom of God will be like a master who summoned his slaves and entrusted them with a tremendous amount of his wealth before he went off on a very long journey.
Jesus is telling us what we are to do while our Master is away. And that’s where things get a little disturbing - right? -because we don’t like the idea that our master is anything like this master in the parable. We don’t like the idea of Jesus being harsh, reaping where he does not sow, or throwing the weak out into the darkness where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.
So my friends, this is as good a time as any to remind you that’s not exactly how parables work.
Parables are not meant to be read as strict allegories where each character stands for God or Jesus or us in a straightforward way. Nor is there a clear moral to each tale. Parables invite us into a story that could mean any number of things and our job is to play with them until we puzzle our way out. They are crafted to disturb and provoke us the better to make us think, wonder, and question what Jesus could possibly mean.
It’s also important for us to remember that the word “parable” literally means to throw two things down side by side for comparison. And in Jesus’ teaching, when he does that, he often uses a rhetorical strategy known as: “how much more?”.
You may remember that when Jesus taught people about prayer he said: Listen, you “give good gifts to your kids when they ask, right? Well how much more so does God desire to give good things to you!"(Matt 7:11)?
Jesus is using that same “how much more” formula here. If this harsh master does things this way…how much more will I do things that way? If the servant did this…how much more should you do that?
The question now is what this and that might be? How much more will Jesus do …what? How much more should we do… what?
To answer that, we need to know what exactly we’re working with, which brings me back to the talents themselves. As I said to the kids, a talent was a huge sum of money - 20 years worth of wages. 5 talents amounted to a hundred years worth of wages.
If this isn’t really a parable about money, what might the talents represent? What priceless treasure did Jesus risk entrusting to his disciples before he left them?
Anyone want to take a guess?
His teachings! Yes! His truth!
Now I could be wrong. I’m sure there are other ways to read this parable. But I can’t help thinking that the talents represent the gospel, everything Jesus has lived for and everything for which he is about to die.
This, to me, is a story about what we are to do with the radical, life changing, mind altering, captive freeing, establishment challenging, teachings of Jesus. If the servants ran off and put the harsh master’s money to work, how much more so should we run off to put Jesus’ teachings to work.
And yet, his gospel - the idea that we can supplant the kingdoms of this world with the kingdom of God by living the way Jesus taught us to live and loving the way Jesus taught us to love - is about to get Jesus arrested and killed.
Which means that the third slave was right to be afraid and not for nothing, but we probably should be too. There is some serious risk involved here if we dare to proceed. The gospel of Jesus is a treasure of vast potential and extreme volatility, more so than even a life time’s worth of wages. And yet, for all that power, if we bury it, it will come to nothing.
“But,” and this is a big but, “ But if you have the courage to take it,” says Jesus, “run with it, work with it, and risk bringing this new way of living and loving out into the world, then the kingdom of God has a shot of coming to earth and when I return we can rejoice together in what has been established.”
Friends, if the harsh master invited his first two slaves to join him in his joy, how much more will Jesus rejoice with us if we’ve risked everything to live out his truths in an effort to build a more just and generous world?
Likewise, if the third slave was thrown out into the darkness for failing to risk anything at all, how much more so will we we mourn our reticence to do what was right and good and true when we had the chance?
Think for a moment about what you regret most in this life…
If you’re anything like me, then you probably regret those times when you didn’t act…didn’t at with kindness or courage…didn’t act with integrity or generosity. And I get it. I don’t say that to judge anyone because I’ve failed more times then I can count.
The truth is that it’s risky to put ourselves out there and give with abandon.
It’s risky to forgive when we’ve been hurt. It’s risky to love each other let alone our enemies.
It’s risky to confront injustice, to call out abuse, to advocate for those on the outside and the underside.
Risky to speak up for Palestinians. Risky to stand between our immigrant siblings and ICE.
Risky to put so much time and effort into developing plans for an ADA restroom or a renovated kitchen when we don’t know where the money will come from.
Risky to not just put our faith into action for the sake of our neighbors, but to let them know that we are acting the way we are acting because we are people of faith.
But if this parable teaches us anything, it teaches us that it’s also risky not to.
Like those slaves, Jesus has handed us all a treasure of vast potential.
The third slave was afraid of what he received, and rightly so. The miracle of this parable is that the first two were not, at least not so afraid that they let their fear stop them from using what they had been given.
In this time of momentous change and tremendous possibility, may God grant us the courage to risk something big for something good…risk living as the good and faithful servants Jesus trusts that we can be. Amen
